An Hour of Who a Day: 08/31/19

August 31: "Resolution"

Promotional photo for "Resolution" (from BBC One - Doctor Who,
Resolution Gallery) ©BBC

Another episode without a title sequence! Does Chibnall not actually like the opening titles?

For the first time since Doctor Who came back in 2005, we don't get a Christmas special; instead, it's been delayed a week until New Year's Day 2019. (The cynical part of me thinks that's because, with the announcement that series 12 won't begin until 2020, this way they could still say Doctor Who had aired in 2019.) And so we get a story tied into New Year's instead of Christmas, but in other respects "Resolution" is basically the same thing we've come to expect. It's a longer, bigger episode, with something to entice the casual viewers, and that "something" is the return of the Daleks. Well, a Dalek, at least. But yes, after a season of new threats and planets, Chibnall finally chooses to dip into the show's past and bring back the audience's favorite monster for the "end of series special".

The opening sequence is a bit odd, though; it's like Chibnall wants to create this epic backstory, with pieces of the Kaled mutant being separated across the globe and defended for centuries by a group called the Order of the Custodians, but then he doesn't really do anything with it. The Kaled mutant is able to teleport itself back together once one of the pieces is revived, without any battle or anything, and so we're kind of left wondering what the point of that was. Chibnall could have just had the whole mutant uncovered and revived in Sheffield without any damage to the plot.

But elsewhere we get a pretty solid tale. Chibnall appears to be borrowing from the episode "Dalek" the idea that a lone Dalek is more terrifying than an army of them, but he puts his own spin on it, with the stuff of the mutant being able to latch onto people (kind of like the spiders in Planet of the Spiders, or the time beetle on Donna's back in "Turn Left") and to take over their bodies being an effective and disturbing threat. Plus it gives Charlotte Ritchie, as Lin, the Dalek's victim, a chance to act evil without compromising the sweetness of her character. And hooray! Despite all the changes from the Moffat era that Chibnall has made, we still get Nick Briggs as the voice of the Dalek!

But in other regards this is a whole new Dalek (described as a special kind of Dalek, a reconnaissance scout, in order to maintain good faith continuity with the older versions of Daleks), with a new look and new weapons, such as missiles behind the giant Dalek "bumps" on the front of the skirt section. (And, in another first, this Dalek was completely radio-operated, with no person inside making it move or anything.) The Dalek looks a little ratty and slightly odd, but that's partly because it's reconstructed its shell from odds and ends. ("What do you call this look, junkyard chic?" the Doctor taunts.) It's a clever way of letting the production team design a new version of a Dalek without having to be married to it, the way the Moffat era was stuck with the iPhone Daleks for a while. And this Dalek is still incredibly dangerous, as shown by the way it takes out a squad of soldiers and a tank without much difficulty, so although the look may be different the danger is just as potent as ever.

So the Dalek storyline proceeds nicely, but we do get some character moments thrown in as well to help sweeten the deal, such as at the beginning, with the Doctor having taken her friends to nineteen New Year's celebrations in a row (and I, like the rest of the world, utterly adore the thirteenth Doctor's scarf here). And Jodie Whittaker has an understated but gorgeous line reading, after she works out that the creature in the sewers is a Kaled mutant: "I always I think I'm rid of them. Never am." But the main character bit is the introduction of Ryan's dad, Aaron, who's been hinted at throughout the season but not actually included until now. What's fascinating about his scenes is that Daniel Adegboyega, playing Aaron, makes him a surprisingly sympathetic character. It's not like when Clyde's dad showed up in The Sarah Jane Adventures; here, it feels like Aaron genuinely has regrets and genuinely wants to make amends as best as he can. This really shines through the scene between Aaron and Graham, where Graham has a box of Aaron's stuff that Grace had kept. "I wish I was better at life, Graham," Aaron says. "Well, there's still time," Graham replies. Aaron comes across as flawed but not irredeemable, and while Ryan's acceptance of his dad at the end feels a bit too easy, it's not the worst thing in the world. And Aaron shows himself to be not completely useless, which is nice; he has some engineering skills that not only allowed him to designed a combination oven and microwave, but also let him come up with the plan to defeat the Dalek, after the Doctor points out that this version has a lot of metal in its shell.

Of course, because this is a holiday special and they're expecting more casual viewers to tune in, they've decided to include some "jokes" in the episode as well. The one about UNIT isn't terrible, with its implication that UNIT was shut down as a result of Brexit ("All UNIT operations were put on hold following financial disputes and subsequent funding withdrawal by the UK's major international partners") -- and hilariously, some pro-Brexit viewers were apparently really upset by this -- but the one about all the WiFi and internet and phones going down starts with a good joke from Graham and Ryan ("What, on New Year's Day, when everything's shut and everyone's hung over?" Graham asks. "What a monster," Ryan replies), but then it cuts to a pretty cringe-inducing scene with a family worried that they'll have to talk to each other now. Less of this in future, please.

So it's not a perfect story by any means, but there's quite a bit to like about "Resolution". The actual Dalek itself is pretty terrifying, and the majority of the story is focused on the Dalek, so this part comes off well. If the surrounding material lets the side down, that just means that "Resolution" is ultimately more a solid tale than a brilliant one. Not a bad way to start the New Year at all.

And so that wraps it up for this run of Doctor Who stories. I hope to see you here again on September 1, 2020, when I'll cover series 12 (currently rumored to be airing early in 2020 -- so they basically just pushed the start date back by a few months, rather than scrapping a year altogether).