October 28: "The Deep" (The War Between the Land and the Sea)

So if the previous two episodes were basically focused on setup, "The Deep" is where things start to move into a new phase.  There's not exactly much in the way of action in this episode (at least, until the last 5 minutes or so), but they've replaced the sense of exposition and plot-maneuvering with one of tension and impending dread.  This, on the whole, is a good thing.

This episode concerns itself primarily that the agreement Barclay made at the end of last episode, to meet Homo aqua on their home turf at the bottom of the Romanche Trench near the west coast of Africa: one of the deepest parts of the ocean.  So we get lots of discussions about the preparations of that descent: getting the diving bell ready, picking a team to accompany Barclay, and seeing Barclay himself open up to his ex-wife about being scared.  This last part helps humanise Barclay, lest we forget that he's been rather unexpectedly thrust into all this.  Because much of the rest of the episode calls on him to be the calm and collected one, particularly in the diving bell while many of his teammates start to experience panic attacks, it's nice to see the more vulnerable side here.

But for large parts of this, Barclay is the level-headed one of the team.  We see a team of six sent down in the diving bell: Barclay, General Pierce, Captain Louise Mackie (one of the UNIT people we've seen working with the Homo aqua language), Min Tso (another UNIT person we've seen doing science things), and two new diplomatic personnel named Ravi (who's rather nervous) and Ted (a friendly South African guy).  They do a good job of wringing tension out of the diving bell scenes with little more than acting and lots of loud bangs and groans from the bell as it adjusts to the pressure.  While Pierce remains perhaps predictably reasonably calm, the others all have moments of anxiety, some more severe than others.  It's good to see each of them get a moment, a bit of characterisation, since it makes us care about them a bit more (along with giving Barclay a chance to show some leadership qualities).

There's also something of a sense of wonder when we see the domain of Homo aqua; the way it looks elegantly organic, while everything is lit in a gentle blue bioluminescent glow, is nicely done.  And while the characters may initially show fear when the diving bell is seized (although why are they so surprised and alarmed by this?   What did they think was going to happen?), we quickly move on to trust from most of the characters (except Ted, for reasons that will soon become clear).  And so while Min gets to show off a bit, discussing the lighting, our focus shifts to a scene between Barclay and Salt that shows a surprising amount of sexual tension.  Their scene is almost crackling with electricity, even though all they're really doing is standing in front of each other and feeling the texture of the other person's skin; nevertheless, Russell Tovey and Gugu Mbatha-Raw have clear chemistry, even with a diving suit and a bunch of prosthetics in the way.

Meanwhile on the surface, tensions are rising, partly in thanks to our cartoon villains from last time.  They're not quite as overtly evil this time, although the way they seem to be running the Prime Minister's meeting for him isn't exactly innocent-looking.  As Kate wonders, why are a civilian and two foreign generals present at an emergency meeting?  We get some waffle from the PM about needing industry on his side, but it doesn't sound terribly convincing, and the way they try to muscle UNIT out of the way is so clumsy that it's a bit surprising that it's working.  I guess this Prime Minister doesn't have a particularly strong backbone (another similarity this shares with Children of Earth).  Then they overegg the pudding with a scene where Sir Keith gets to be cartoonishly evil again, making quips about how the PM likes Sir Keith's money and hinting at something called "Severance" (probably not the Apple show).  Come on, Pete McTighe, I know these guys are villains but couldn't you have given them at least a little more subtlety?

So we get conflict and tension both on land and in the sea, and things start to really come to a head at the end.  The way they juxtapose Kate's (attempted) assassination with the reveal that Ted, who's spent a bunch of time being likable, is really working for Sir Keith and company (well, probably), having smuggled some sort of weapon in as a gift, does mean that this episode ends on a suitably dramatic note (which is also a change from the last two cliffhangers, which both end on Russell Tovey saying "OK").  It does raise some vetting questions from UNIT again though, if this diplomatic representative can smuggle a weapon into their mission; who's clearing these people?  It's like we're back to the slightly ramshackle days of '70s UNIT again.  And so help me, if they kill Colonel Ibrahim (the way that ending shot, his having taken a bullet meant for Kate, seems to imply), I will be very very unhappy.

So yeah, this is definitely picking up.  I'm interested to see what happens next.